Skip to main content

A USMNT Fan's Guide to the 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs (Western Conference First Round Edition)

The departures of USMNT stars might define the Western Conference side of the MLS playoff bracket.
ByNoah Guttman
Houston Dynamo FC v San Jose Earthquakes
Houston Dynamo FC v San Jose Earthquakes | Joe Buvid/ISI Photos/GettyImages

After doing the same for the Eastern Conference, one can make the argument that the Western Conference seems a little more straightforward to predict. Does that mean the teams on the other side of the bracket are better? Not necessarily.

Rather, it's a question of how the bracket is set up. There are some upset-worthy matchups on the Western side of the bracket, but it's the East where more of the trap ties can be found. Here's what the first phase of that path looks like based on my projections.

#1 Vancouver Whitecaps vs #9 Salt Lake

Canada's lone MLS Cup title might belong to Toronto FC, but Canadian MLS sides have been to MLS Cup four times over the past 10 seasons. That includes Vancouver's run to last season's MLS Cup game, which saw them dispatch LAFC after years of trying and put together a dominant effort against San Diego in the Western Conference Final.

After surviving the departure of USMNT mainstay Sebastian Berhalter and securing the West's top seed for the first time in club history, the Whitecaps will look to extend both of those numbers by one.

The Whitecaps have scored the second-most total goals of any MLS side, with USMNT forward Brian White recording 20 of them. This is also a team that can flip the field very quickly; they've recorded the seventh-most free kicks, the fourth-highest number of corners, and the second-best long-ball percentage of any MLS side.

Can they get another run going against Salt Lake? That could be a tricky matchup.

Need I say more?

Salt Lake goalkeeper Rafael Cabral was the MVP of his team's Wild Card match against the Seattle Sounders, making three saves (one of which was on a penalty) while stopping two of Seattle's penalties during the shootout.

If Salt Lake can find some scoring, they should be able to prove that they were indeed the tougher of the Whitecaps' two possible first-round opponents. Salt Lake forces the series to three games, but the Whitecaps will do enough to win it.

Prediction: Vancouver Whitecaps win in three games

#2 FC Dallas vs #7 Portland Timbers

It's Petar Musa, who finished second to Messi in the MLS Golden Boot race and recorded 28 total goal contributions, versus the Timbers' in-form scoring. The neck-and-neck nature of that battle is further represented by the fact that the two clubs scored the same number of goals this season.

This series should go the distance, but it will be very interesting to see what happens if Portland takes Game 1. After all, the Timbers Army is known to be one of the best fan bases in the league; the chance to knock one of the top MLS Cup contenders out of the postseason altogether would give Game 2 in Portland that much more of an atmosphere. Even if Portland loses Game 1, there is enough talent on this Timbers team to give them a chance at winning the series. They'll get it done, but it will likely go the distance.

Prediction: Portland Timbers win in three games

#3 St. Louis City vs #6 LAFC

St. Louis City can challenge the best of the Western Conference; this much is true. The problem? St. Louis City could not get out of their own way to end the season; they lost four of their last five MLS contests. It will be up to the likes of United States under-23 midfielder Daniel Edelman and an on-loan Damion Downs to try and kickstart this St. Louis City side once again.

Both St. Louis City and LAFC can be dangerous playoff teams at their peak. But at this time, it's hard to see both of these teams sustaining a deep run to the MLS Cup Final. As much as I'd love to abstain on this series, one of them has to get to the next round. Even with the significant scoring disparity in mind, I'm backing LAFC to pull off the semi-upset and end what has generally been a positive season for St. Louis City.

Prediction: LAFC wins in three games

#4 San Jose vs #5 Houston Dynamo

Is the Houston Dynamo the odd one out? They've scored the fewest goals of any 2026 playoff team across their 34 regular-season games. But at the same time, they've conceded the third-fewest of the Western Conference's playoff teams and the fourth-fewest when considering both sides of the MLS Cup playoff bracket. Of course, they won just two of their final 12 games of the season, all of which came after USMNT midfielder Jack McGlynn left the club for Stoke City.

The statistics back that picture up to some extent. Houston conceded the sixth-fewest shots and third-fewest fouls of any MLS team, though they are 10th when it comes to clearances. That said, San Jose is 16th, 18th, and 19th in those same categories.

Unless the Dynamo can possess the ball and defend well enough beyond their final third to frustrate San Jose and take a 1-0 lead heading back to Houston, this series shouldn't go any further than two matches. It's quite hard to see a side defend for 270 consecutive minutes and emerge victorious; I don't see a world where Houston does so in a competitive fashion for even two-thirds of that time.

Prediction: San Jose wins in two games

Add us as a preferred source on Google